Are They Real or Fake?

jazz fakebook

If you have been a musician for a little bit of time, and certainly if you’ve been one for a long time, you have probably come across a fake book of some kind.  These are usually huge volumes of tunes, be it jazz standards, pop hits, blues songs, broadway classics, or any number of genres.  Many musicians, especially gigging musicians, will often invest in one or more of these tomes to increase their personal database of tunes.

But what is a Fake Book, and where did they come from?  The first question is easiest to answer with a picture (You know what they say, a picture is worth a thousand words).

Cantaloupe

A fake book is a collection of lead sheets.  These sheets will have the chords symbols, the basic melody, and notated chords/harmony, generally no more than one or two sheets of music per tune.  A fake book could contain hundreds of such sheets, making it a very economical way to learn tunes or bring music to a gig.

The question of where fake books come from is a little longer, and as always, a little history is worthwhile.  At the turn of the 20th century, households did not have televisions, computers, or the internet.  What many families did have, was a piano.  Gathering around the instrument and singing/playing was a great American past time.  The popularity of sheet music was enormous.  With the rise of the parlor guitar, the banjo, the ukulele, and other such small instruments, chord diagrams were also included in the music.  Ukulele fingering charts were actually more popular than guitar until the 1950’s.  While this was useful as a form of entertainment, buying individual tunes was very impractical for the professional musician.  Buying one song at a time, with a full piano score, was expensive and in-efficient, due to all the pages required.  This situation was not ideal for any gigging musician.  Out of this system came “lead sheets,” consisting of a melody line, chord symbols, and a lyric for vocal tunes.  If you were unfamiliar with a tune, you could use this sheet to “fake it.”

Initially, all “fake books” were hand written transcriptions that ignored trifles like licenses or copyrights.  A company by the name of Tune Dex inadvertently aided this shady activity by printing the choruses of popular songs on 3×5 index cards with ordering information for their catalogs on the other side.  These were intended s a promotional item to get musicians to buy the tunes, but instead, they would just collect the cards to use in their homemade fake books.

TuneDex

 

tune-dex very good advice back blog

 

Tune Dex and other publishers were not terribly proactive in in monitoring the distribution of these cards, so they were spread prolifically.  When legal action was taken, it was half-hearted at best.  An attempt to uphold the “spirit of the law,” if you will.  Apart from the legal concerns that musicians faced by using “fake books,” these sketchy compilations were often wrong musically, or contained poor chord and harmony choices.

Finally, in the late 1960’s, the first legal fake book was published for which royalties were actually paid out to the songwriters.  Increasingly more and more publishers were releasing their own legal fake books through the 1970’s.  Publisher Hal Leonard released the Ultimate Fake Book in 1981.  Since that time, the Hal Leonard “Real Book” series has been one of the leaders in legal fake book publication.

Fake books have become a staple in many musician’s arsenal of tools.  Perhaps you’re one of them?  If not, please browse our selection of fake books!  I’m sure you can find something that will pique your interest or help you knowledge of tunes.

3 comments on “Are They Real or Fake?”

  1. Herb Mickman Reply

    all the hal leonard real books are full of mistakes . .some songs have the wrong title and wrong composer. I’m a jazz musician and teacher with 60 years experience.i can back up what I’m saying by showing you the correct version in other books.i found dozens of songs written right in other hal leonard books.his editors are making all kinds of errors and don’t have a sharp proof reader.some of his editors are not good musicians.some have tried to improve on gershwin,rodgers and porter.these are fairly expencive books.they should have the correct melody .one song had 18 mistakes.lots of people buy these books and play the songs wrong.

  2. Herb Mickman Reply

    i have written hal leonard 5 or 6 letters.i got no answer.they don’t care.the sher books are much better.i taught a jazz piano class at ucla for 18 years and told the students to buy these fake books.im sorry to tell you this but don’t buy a real book.some songs are right but there are some bad ones.

  3. Bernard Giles Reply

    Herb Mickman
    Had collected a lifelong inventory of great chords and voicings of standards and jazz tunes. He also
    taught at UCLA…WHERE
    or How can his inventory be located or found…Does ANYONE know?

Leave A Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *